Ahead of the Times: Why Presbyterian Churches Still Need Organists
The Presbyterian Church risks losing a form of musical and congregational capability in Australia that it may later wish it had preserved. Although this essay is music-related, its purpose is to promote worshipping and glorying the Lord. ‘Let everything that has breath praise the LORD!’ (Ps.150: 1-6)
Contemporary Christian songs have a legitimate place in church life — church bands and contemporary arrangements can be engaging and accessible. Nevertheless, a church that has only one musical vocabulary is impoverished compared with a church that can draw upon both.
Sadly, displacement happens in dealing with contemporary songs and historic hymns. So, put to the side for now whether churches own organs or not, or occasionally sing hymns. This is not about whether Presbyterian churches should embrace contemporary Christian songs or traditional hymn-singing. The question is whether we are inadvertently allowing one to displace the other until the musical resources needed for the other are no longer available.
The either/or case will become redundant if there are insufficient numbers of people in the future having the musicianship, education, training and experience to accompany congregational hymn-singing effectively. The concern is with the disappearance of a skill-set in Australia.
Thoughts on how being a church organist could possibly be cool might puzzle some readers; so, listen in first to this link: https://youtu.be/rTwEm_yE704?si=1aJOT6N3QPJBvoCg (Gert van Hoef & Paul Fey play ‘The Power of Your Love’ — digital organ), and young Ben Maton has been presenting the issue. With 163 evocative videos so far, he now has 200,000 subscribers. Here is Ben on, for instance, ‘A Giant of All Hymns – Amazing Grace’ https://youtu.be/UtfxMdkS0OY?si=bVE0xYvXtKbSqkKM .
There are issues that need to be kept separate in our minds. Let us be aware of distinctions such as between having an organ in the church, having someone who can play the organ, having someone who can accompany congregational singing confidently and sensitively, and having a developing culture in which musicians are encouraged to acquire those skills both in their local level and also by the wider church, or even societal, structure.
These components are not interchangeable. Organists who understand congregational singing do more than play the notes. They provide musical leadership, establish a confident tempo and a singable key, give the tune clarity, support the congregation’s breathing and phrasing, and musically colour, undergird and nuance each verse of a hymn’s words so that everyday people can sing heartily.
Often congregations love singing together, ‘singing their heads off’, ‘singing their hearts out’. Hymn-singing has this effect when everyday people are encountering the Lordship of Jesus Christ, because the hymn is as inspirational as that. Welsh hymn-singing festivals cymanfa ganu also have this effect.
The concern here is about how to enable congregations to sing robustly, enthusiastically and wholeheartedly, rather than feeling like audiences attending a music presentation.
Let me draw an analogy with healthy diets. A healthy diet requires more than an adequate quantity of food. It involves the right nutrients in the right proportions. Similarly, healthy church music requires more than a steady supply of contemporary songs, arrangements and resources. It calls for musical literacy and a knowledge of hymnody. It calls for musicians capable of accompanying congregational singing. It calls for opportunities for musicians to learn within the church settings that enable organists to develop.
Let us think about a church culture that values congregational participation in singing hymns. Just as it is unwise to make fast-food the staple diet likewise, while contemporary Christian music has a part to play, an over-reliance upon it can leave churches progressively undernourished in other important areas of musical and congregational life.
And a vital skill-set disappears. Pastors and church organists already are reporting difficulties in finding competent organists. This is not surprising when the avenues in Australia that once encouraged younger generations to acquire organ accompaniment skills have become abandoned.
All is not lost though. The trend is reversible through practical action.
Some of the easier measures to take are being taken. Churches know already to identify and encourage musicians with musical ability; however, perhaps the Presbyterian Church at each state level should be investigating the impediments being implied herein. Learning to accompany congregational hymn-singing, even on a piano, is a particular skill that warrants not only formal lessons but encouragement, mentoring and practical experience.
Hymn-singing is to be valued in church life. If congregations rarely sing hymns, there will be fewer opportunities for organists to develop their skills. The two declining trends reinforce each other. That insight is crucial: this problem is potentially self-perpetuating. Fewer opportunities to play lead to fewer organists; fewer organists make hymn-singing more difficult to sustain; and declining hymn-singing creates still fewer opportunities for organists.
Hymns have often become regarded as passé, ‘old school’, behind the times — and that is an assumption warranting reconsideration. Consider the counterfactual: that perhaps hymn-singing is ahead of our times.
The historic body of hymns offers something that contemporary musical fashions cannot necessarily replicate: a rich inheritance of Christian theological reflection; a vocabulary of praise, lament, thanksgiving and confession; a connection of the generations of Christians and of geographically diverse Christians; and opportunities for congregations to express substantial theological truths together. Hymnody provides a repertoire that has been tested and sung across centuries.
The case for hymn-singing implies something distinctly Presbyterian: taking seriously the importance of words, theology, congregational participation and the formation of Christian understanding.
This is not to claim that all hymns are automatically superior to contemporary songs. The point is, rather, that a church that retains access to what is traditional and what is contemporary possesses a vital, and richer, inheritance.
And, arguably, the churches deliberately preserving this inheritance may eventually be seen as ahead of the times!
The most concerning aspect of this subtle decline is that we have become accustomed to it. Perhaps across Australia’s Presbyterian churches, an air of quiet resignation has developed over the decades: fewer organists are coming through, fewer churches are maintaining a culture of hymn-singing, and the assumption is that this is simply how things are going to be.
But why should this be so? There is nothing inevitable about the disappearance of church organists. There is nothing inevitable about the decline of congregational hymn-singing. Both substantially depend upon the choices we make now — about what we value, what we encourage and what we are prepared to cultivate.
We do not need to be choosing either contemporary Christian music or hymn-singing. We do not need to be choosing between church bands and church organs.
But we do need to recognise that, if we allow the skills and musicianship associated with hymn-singing to disappear, then recovering them later may be considerably harder than preserving them now.
Perhaps it is time for Presbyterian churches across Australia to ask if hymn-singing actually is behind the times. In an age when so much of our musical experience is commercially produced and consumed, congregations who are singing their hearts out together accompanied by suitable organists may be something ahead of the times.
If so, then there are practical implications to be addressed, and in Psalm 40:3 the Lord highlights His ‘new song’.
– Ruth Williams